Last week, everyone in our office received an email from Stubhub telling us that our credit cards were about to be charged $2500 for a transaction we hadn’t authorized. The first person to get the email became extremely worried, went to Stubhub’s website – which was down at that moment, and then called her credit card company, who told her they’d received many other calls on the same subject and that everything was probably ok, but to watch her next bill just in case. Soon we saw that everyone else in the office got the email and we were no longer worried because we figured it was a phishing scheme.
This got me thinking – what worried us so much about this email? After all, we receive lots of spam messages every day and usually don’t worry about it. I know my bank won’t ask for personal information via email, and neither will the IRS. I know not to send all my money to Nigeria to become a millionaire (if only it was that easy).
I think it was a combination of factors. First, it was a lot of money, but not so much that it seemed ridiculous. Second, we know Stubhub is a legitimate company and that it conducts business online, so it seemed possible that this email could be true. Because I have never interacted with Stubhub in an offline way, this scam seemed more believable.
I think this is an interesting shift in what we think makes a company “real.” There are many times when people worry that a business may not be real because they cannot find any evidence of it online. This is often a problem for small businesses that need to establish credibility. On the flip side, some businesses need to engage in traditional marketing activities to seem real. Stubhub does extensive advertising to promote its services. We assumed any company with a big enough budget to advertise on Ryan Seacrest’s radio show must be real. Sometimes, direct mail can make a company seem more real. After all, snail mail costs a lot more money than email.
I think it is worth considering what makes any business seem “real.” For every business, the answer will be different. Each business needs to consider how it interacts with customers, their expectations for that business’ behavior, and the many ways they can build trust. I think it most cases, it means relying on more than one method of communication. More communication = more effort and hopefully, more effort = real. (Except when you’re phishing.)
Christina Steder is the President of Clear Verve Marketing and works with clients to plan, create and execute marketing campaigns. Follow her on Twitter as @clearverve